JoeBlogs

JoeBlogs

Beginning “Baseball’s One Percenters”

Kicking off our new Friday series about players who statistically rank in the Top 1%, but are not in the Hall of Fame.

Nov 20, 2026
∙ Paid

OK, let’s officially introduce our new series for Clubhouse members: Baseball’s One Percenters …

If you’d like to join The Clubhouse, now’s a great time — until the end of the month, we’re offering a special $50 annual subscription, $20 off the normal price.


A few years ago, I did a series called The Outsiders, in which I counted down the 100 best players who hadn’t been inducted into the Hall of Fame. That series is out of date now — thirteen of the players on the list have been inducted since I wrote it.

But I’ve also started thinking about the Hall of Fame differently.

Welcome to Baseball’s One Percenters.

Today, I’ll explain how I came up with this new list of 100 fantastic players not in the Hall of Fame. After today — I won’t talk about the methods again. The point here is to tell stories. To reveal greatness.

But you might want to know how I did this, so let’s begin here: Every player on this list is really, really good. Put it this way: If you took out the bottom 100 players in the Hall of Fame by combo-WAR — that is, the average of Baseball-Reference and Fangraphs WAR — and replaced them with the 100 on this list, the Hall of Fame would gain MORE THAN A THOUSAND wins above replacement.

How crazy is that? Now, of course, a lot of that is due to those tainted players — in the series, I will call them “cloud” players — like Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens and Alex Rodríguez, whose exclusion from the Hall has nothing to do with their value as players. But even if you don’t count the cloud players, the Hall would STILL gain more than 600 wins. These are ALL terrific players and legit Hall of Fame candidates.

The reason: They’re all one-percenters. I have spent weeks putting together a series of one-percent lists. There have been 23,800 or so players in baseball history. I wanted the top one percent of them in various categories.

Those lists are:

  1. Career value list (pitchers and hitters). The top 238 players since 1901 by Baseball Reference and Fangraphs WAR. In the last couple of days (thanks to a suggestion from Tom Tango), I added a postseason-play bonus. So, take Sandy Koufax. Obviously, he’s already in the Hall of Fame, but he’s a good example — by regular career value, he ranks 255th on the list, which is just outside the top 1%. Makes sense: He famously had a short career. But with the postseason bonus, he skyrockets up to 194th, well inside the top 1%.

  2. Peak value (hitters): The top 160 hitters by their five best WAR seasons. I went with five seasons rather than more or less because it just worked best for me.

  3. Peak value (pitchers): The top 78 pitchers by their best five seasons, each measured against that year’s typical ace.

  4. Offense (hitters): The top 160 hitters by their career batting value.

  5. Peak offense (hitters): The top 160 hitters by their best five offensive seasons.

  6. Defense (hitters): The top 160 position players in career fielding value.

  7. Dominance (pitchers): The top 78 pitchers by their best five years of strikeouts, walks, and hits allowed compared against their leagues.

Now, you will ask: How many mistakes do you think you made in all these calculations? The answer: A bajillion-shmillion, I’m sure. But I think and hope I got the big stuff right.

I believe that every single player on this list is a one-percenter.

That, alas, is not true of the Hall of Fame. By my calculations — not counting Negro Leaguers, relievers, or 19th-century pitchers — 33 players in the Hall of Fame didn’t make any of my 1 percent lists.

Join The Clubhouse for $50/year

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Joe Posnanski.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Joe Posnanski · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.