For many years, I’ve been fascinated by the Hall of Fame’s claim that “Of the more than 23,000 men who have played Major League Baseball, just 1 percent have been enshrined in Cooperstown.” It’s a striking image, isn’t it? Only one percent! Only the best of the best, right?
Right?
When you look at the basic numbers, the Hall of Fame’s claim more or less adds up. According to Baseball Reference, 23,803 players have played Major League Baseball. This includes the Negro Leagues.
There are 281 players (including the Negro Leaguers) in the Hall of Fame.
That’s 1.18%.
So yeah, that’s a real thing.
But there is something about the whole 1% thing that feels just a little off, and it took me a long time to unlock it. Sure, the Hall of Fame is exclusive; few would argue that point. There are only 281 players enshrined. That’s because so few are selected every year.
But do those 281 players make up the TOP 1% of all players?
How would you even determine such a thing? What does it even mean to be one of the top 1%? Are we talking about career value? Are we talking about peak value? Are we talking about fame? What even is fame? Are the top 1% of his batters in the Hall of Fame? How about the top 1% of fielders?
So I decided to dive in. I broke down every player in various categories. Who makes up the top 1% of offensive players? Who are the top 1% fielders? Which starters are in the Top 1% over the length of their careers, and which ones were the most dominant over a short span?
Essentially, I was looking for every player who could make a claim to being in the top 1% in something. I was as generous as I could be about what 1% means and found that roughly 650 players qualify as top 1% in at least one of the categories. Rick Dempsey is a top 1% fielder. Adam Dunn and George Foster are top 1% batters. Floyd Bannister had a Top 1% dominant peak as a pitcher. Cole Hamels’s pitching career is in the top 1%. Etc.*
*You will now ask: Were there any Hall of Famers who did not make the top 1% in any category? I will save the details for its own special post but, um, yeah, a bunch of them.
Once I had the list of the one-percenters, I tried to determine which 100 non-Hall of Fame one-percenters are most worthy of election to Cooperstown.
Starting Friday, I will be writing about those 100 players every week here on JoeBlogs. I’m basically writing a book in real time for our Clubhouse members. I think you’ll get a kick out of it. There are some names on the list that, frankly, shocked me. And you can try to guess who I think is the most worthy player not in the Hall of Fame, but it’s likely you won’t guess. I would not have.
To give you a better idea of what this One Percent idea looks like, I have broken down this year’s Hall of Fame Ballot for our Clubhouse readers. If you’d like to join the Clubhouse, now’s a great time: Until November 30, you can get JoeBlogs for $50 a year, $20 off the regular price.



