JoeBlogs

JoeBlogs

Salary Caps and Floors

A closer examination of MLB’s argument for why the league needs both and how they would work.

Nov 19, 2026
∙ Paid
(Elsa/Getty Images)

We’re not going to focus too much on MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred’s comments Wednesday because, you know, what’s there to say about a commissioner who blurts out “there’s plenty of room to compromise,” and then, in the very same paragraph, says that the owners “want a salary cap and floor, and on that we will not compromise.” I mean, what can you even do with that? This whole stupid fight is about a salary cap. You can’t say that there’s room to compromise when you also say, right up front, that you refuse to compromise. I believe Socrates came up with that.

Manfred also said he’s not that big on Thanksgiving as a holiday.

Alas, Rob Manfred is not very good at, you know, talking.

Instead, let’s go deep into the owners’ pitch for a salary cap and floor. We’re about to have a baseball lockout. Let’s see what MLB is pitching.

A couple of days ago, Major League Baseball Executive Vice President Morgan Sword — whom I consider one of the smartest and most thoughtful people in baseball — put out a video called, conveniently enough, “The Case for a Salary Cap and Floor.”

I think there’s a lot in it worth talking about — most of it’s spin and misdirection, sure, but these are also the league’s best arguments for convincing the players to allow a salary cap after sixty years of successfully refusing to accept it.

Here’s the video:

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Joe Posnanski.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Joe Posnanski · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.