Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steve Goldberg's avatar

Novak is the mentally toughest player to ever play the game. He dominates and intimidates everyone not named Rafa and Roger. For years I’d picked Fed and Nadal as the top two GOATS, but that was, I see now, simply me choosing whose tennis styles I preferred, not who legitimately is/was the best. I really want to see a final between DJokovic and Alcaraz, the only person under 30 I think can beat Novak at full strength. I don’t put his feelings on vaccines or diet or politics above what he does on the court. If I had to choose who I would want to spend a weekend hangout out with, I’d pick Rafa and Roger in a heartbeat but I had the pleasure of meeting Novak in person at Indian Wells and he was the warmest, most down-to-earth pro-player I’ve ever met. I can see him getting to 30 Grand Slams if he doesn’t get hurt.

Edward's avatar

I still think Federer at his absolute best is better than Djokovic at his absolute best — there were even a couple of years there at the end of Federer’s career where it felt like he was the only player on tour who had a chance against Novak in big matches on grass and hard courts — but that’s kind of irrelevant. From a historical standpoint Novak is going to go down as the best with the most weeks at #1 and almost certainly the most major championships as well.

Also, I loved that tennis countdown. I think you’re misrepresenting it slightly since it wasn’t just his personal opinion; he mainly used peak ELO rankings. Not across the board since that wasn’t feasible for the early 20th century players, but it was a bit different than someone just ranking whoever they personally thought was the best. That obviously doesn’t make it objectively correct, though.

20 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?